Results of the APA's Journal Surveys Project​ (2019-2023)

The PJIP recently published a report in the Blog of the APA looking into the results of the APA's Journal Surveys Project. You can read the full report on the APA's website here: 'Insights from the American Philosophical Association’s Journal Surveys Project'.

As mentioned at the end of the report, to make assessing relative journal results easier, the results have been placed into an interactive table below. The table can be filtered to show comparative performance in the following areas: response times, % of manuscripts returned to authors with comments, average quality of comments, and average experience with editors. ​(If not working on mobile an alternative version available here).

   Loading...

Rank	Journal	Number of Surveys	Review Length (in months)	Comment Chances (%)	Comment Quality (out of 5)	Exp. with Editors (out of 5)
	Philosophical Studies	106	3.67	63%	3.18	3.15
	Analysis	86	1.75	85%	3.52	4.01
	Australasian Journal of Philosophy	73	2.89	89%	3.17	3.87
	Synthese	69	3.52	99%	3.72	4.24
	Ergo	67	1.47	66%	3.72	3.8
	The Philosophical Quarterly	62	2.32	71%	3.3	3.81
	Philosophy and Phenomenological Research	54	2.48	26%	2.93	3
	Philosophers' Imprint	49	2.18	31%	2.67	3.21
	Nous	49	2.56	37%	3.39	3.19
	Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy	45	2.68	56%	3.68	3.61
	Mind	44	3.01	34%	3.67	3.09
	Ethics	41	3.2	39%	3.75	2.94
	Pacific Philosophical Quarterly	36	7.05	31%	2.91	2.03
	Journal of Philosophy	35	5.55	69%	2.54	3.03
	European Journal of Philosophy	33	3.37	45%	3.2	2.96
	Journal of Moral Philosophy	32	2.91	28%	3.22	3.08
	Canadian Journal of Philosophy	31	3.08	52%	3.31	3.17
	Philosophy & Public Affairs	30	1.75	60%	3.72	3.56
	Journal of the American Philosophical Association	30	2.35	90%	3.41	4